The best old ice cube tray is designed for those who appreciate classic design and reliable performance for everyday chilling needs. Unlike modern alternatives that can be flimsy or complex, vintage-style trays offer simplicity and durability. Choosing the wrong one can lead to frustratingly stuck ice, cracked plastic, and a less-than-ideal beverage experience.
Factors like material, flexibility, and ease of removal significantly impact satisfaction. To help you find a reliable and charming addition to your kitchen, we’ve curated a list of top-performing old ice cube trays in 2026, ensuring you get the perfect, easy-release cubes you desire.
For the best old ice cube tray experience focusing on durability and odor-free ice, consider a stainless steel option like the one from OXO Good Grips, which offers a plastic-free and non-toxic alternative to prevent ice from absorbing freezer odors and cracking over time. Alternatively, for slow-melting large cubes ideal for cocktails, the 2-inch silicone trays from FDDBI or KitchFort provide an easy-release design.
Best Old Ice Cube Tray Picks Compared
| Image | Product | Buy |
|---|---|---|
Best Pick 1  | OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray Best for: Spill-free refills | Check Price |
Best Pick 2  | Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Best for: Whiskey enrichment | Check Price |
Best Pick 3  | Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Best for: Extra large cubes | Check Price |
Best Pick 4  | Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: 2″ Big Silicone Ice Best for: Bourbon enjoyment | Check Price |
Best Pick 5  | KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Best for: Easy cube release | Check Price |
How We Picked
To determine the best old ice cube tray, we prioritized build quality, real-world performance, and durability. We evaluated each product based on its material construction; for instance, the stainless steel tray offered a plastic-free, non-toxic option. Ease of ice release, lid functionality for odor prevention and stacking, and overall user convenience were key performance indicators.
We ruled out trays that showed signs of potential cracking or material degradation over time. Standout features like unique cube shapes or easy-release mechanisms also influenced our final selection, ensuring we identified a tray built to last and perform exceptionally.
What Most Buyers Get Wrong
No More Freezer Odor Contamination
Old ice cube trays, especially those without lids, are notorious for absorbing the strong smells of other items in your freezer. This can leave your ice tasting and smelling like last night’s onions or forgotten fish. Look for trays with effective, well-fitting lids, like the OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray or the OXO Good Grips Silicone Small Ice Cube Tray with Lid, to create a barrier and keep your ice tasting fresh and pure.
The “Easy Release” Illusion Explained
Many modern trays tout easy release, but older designs sometimes relied on a simple, sturdy plastic or metal that, with a bit of practice, yielded cubes reliably. Silicone trays, like the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray or FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube trays, offer flexibility, but the trick is learning the right amount of twist or push without tearing. For a completely different approach, the stainless steel tray mentioned offers a mechanical lever for a unique, plastic-free release mechanism.
1. OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
Best for: No-spill design for upright freezer storage.
A sealed lid on this OXO Good Grips tray locks in water, preventing drips and spills during transport to the freezer. This allows for upright storage, maximizing freezer space and keeping your ice free from odors. The innovative rounded cube shape is designed for easy release.
The silicone lid fully encloses the tray, allowing it to be stored upright and stacked. This design prevents ice from absorbing ambient freezer odors. The tray itself produces cubes with a rounded shape, facilitating effortless removal from the flexible silicone.
Pros
- Sealed lid prevents spills during transport
- Upright storage maximizes freezer space
- Keeps ice from absorbing freezer odors
- Rounded cube shape for easy release
Cons
- Silicone lid must be removed for cleaning
This OXO tray is ideal for those who need a spill-proof solution for everyday ice. Its stackable design makes it a practical choice for maximizing freezer organization.
2. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube
Best for: Large, slow-melting cubes for cocktails.
Each cavity on the FDDBI silicone ice cube tray is independent, allowing for easy pushing from the bottom to release large, individually formed cubes. This non-sticky, flexible surface ensures your whiskey ice releases smoothly every time. A tight-fitting silicone lid keeps ice fresh.
This set produces large, square ice cubes from two trays, each featuring individual compartments. The non-stick, flexible silicone provides for easy removal, while the removable lid prevents odor absorption and keeps ice clean. The independent cavities ensure uniform cubes.
Pros
- Independent cavities for easy cube removal
- Non-stick silicone surface for smooth release
- Tight-fitting lid prevents odor absorption
- Produces large, uniform cubes
Cons
- Trays are not designed for upright storage
For cocktail enthusiasts seeking to minimize dilution, these FDDBI trays create large, slow-melting ice. Their easy-release design is perfect for unwinding with a drink.
3. Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches
Best for: Value pack with spheres and cubes.
This Samuelworld combo pack offers exceptional value by including both 2.5-inch sphere ice ball trays and giant ice cube trays, yielding 4 spheres and 6 cubes per set. Constructed from high-quality, BPA-free silicone, these trays are built for durability and ease of use with an integrated funnel system.
The 2.5-inch ice ball mold creates large spheres, while the giant ice cube tray forms substantial cubes, offering variety for beverages. Both are made from durable, BPA-free silicone. The trays feature an integrated funnel for efficient filling, simplifying the ice-making process.
Pros
- Includes both sphere and cube molds
- Large 2.5-inch sphere size
- Made from durable, BPA-free silicone
- Integrated funnel for easy filling
Cons
- Sphere mold requires careful filling to avoid leaks
This Samuelworld bundle is perfect for hosts who enjoy offering a variety of large ice formats. It provides great value for crafting impressive spheres and cubes for any beverage.
4. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: 2″ Big Silicone Ice
Best for: Set of three trays for big ice.
Three GGUW silicone ice cube trays are included, each designed with independent cavities for effortless large ice cube release. The non-stick silicone surface ensures big cubes slide out smoothly without sticking. A tight-fitting silicone lid prevents spills and odor absorption.
This collection provides three trays capable of producing large, 2-inch ice cubes. The individual compartments are crafted from soft silicone, allowing easy pushing from the bottom. The lid seals tightly to prevent freezer odor contamination and potential leaks.
Pros
- Set of three trays for ample ice production
- Non-stick silicone for easy release
- Tight-fitting lid prevents odor and spills
- Large 2-inch cube size
Cons
- Cubes may be too large for some glasses
With three trays in this GGUW set, you’ll always have large ice ready for your favorite drinks. The spill-proof lid design makes them a reliable choice for any home bar setup.
5. KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″
Best for: Versatile trays for food and drinks.
The KitchFort large silicone ice cube trays, sold as a 2-pack, are crafted from food-grade, BPA-free silicone for versatile use. Beyond creating 2-inch slow-melting ice cubes for cocktails, they are also safe for freezing baby food, purees, and homemade portions, offering excellent value.
These two durable, BPA-free silicone trays each produce twelve 2-inch ice cubes. The separate cavities ensure effortless removal by twisting and pushing from the bottom. They are also dishwasher safe, making cleanup simple, and suitable for freezing various food items.
Pros
- Food-grade, BPA-free silicone
- Creates 2-inch slow-melting ice cubes
- Safe for freezing baby food and purees
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
Cons
- Silicone can retain strong odors if not cleaned promptly
For those needing versatile freezer storage, these KitchFort trays are perfect for both large ice cubes and batch-prepping food. The double pack offers great utility for busy households.
6. OXO Good Grips Silicone Small Ice Cube Tray with Lid
Best for: Compact uniform cubes with a base support.
Designed for everyday use, the OXO Good Grips silicone small ice cube tray comes with a sturdy base that supports the tray during filling, transport, and storage in the freezer. The flexible silicone makes ice cubes uniform and easy to remove. A removable cover helps keep ice fresh.
This single ice cube tray produces small, uniform cubes. The accompanying lid prevents ice from absorbing freezer odors and allows for stacking multiple trays. The silicone tray itself is flexible, enabling easy ice extraction after freezing. The base provides stability when full.
Pros
- Sturdy base for stability during filling
- Lid prevents freezer odor absorption
- Stackable design for efficient storage
- Flexible silicone for easy cube release
Cons
- Produces smaller cubes, not ideal for slow-melting
This OXO Good Grips tray is perfect for individuals who need small, consistent ice cubes for everyday beverages. Its stable design and odor-blocking lid make it a fuss-free option.
7. W&P Crystal Ice Tray, Perfect Etched Large Cubes, Slow Melting
Best for: Decorative etched large cubes.
The W&P Crystal Ice Tray crafts four large, 2-inch cubes with an intricate etched, geometric design that resembles cut crystals. These unique cubes are engineered for slow melting, ensuring minimal dilution and maximum enjoyment of your beverage. Filling is made easy via a top hole.
This tray creates four distinct, large 2-inch cubes featuring an etched crystal-like pattern. The design incorporates a filling hole at the top and a side hole to indicate when the cube is full, ensuring perfectly formed ice. Removing the ice is achieved by running the bottom under warm water.
Pros
- Creates decorative, crystal-like ice cubes
- Produces large 2-inch slow-melting cubes
- Minimal dilution for beverages
- Unique filling system aids precision
Cons
- Requires a specific release method using warm water
For those who appreciate presentation, this W&P Crystal Ice Tray elevates any drink with its uniquely designed, large ice cubes. It’s perfect for special occasions or adding a touch of elegance to routine enjoyment.
8. OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray
Best for: Individual cube release with stacking lid.
An innovative sliding lid on the OXO Good Grips ice cube tray allows you to release as many cubes as you need at one time, without exposing the rest of the ice. The sturdy lid facilitates efficient stacking, preventing ice from absorbing freezer odors. Cubes are designed with a rounded shape for easy removal.
This tray features a unique lid that slides open to dispense individual ice cubes, preserving the remaining ice. Its sturdy construction allows for stacking multiple trays, and the cover prevents the absorption of unwanted freezer odors. The rounded shape ensures cubes are easily extracted.
Pros
- Slides to release individual cubes
- Sturdy lid enables efficient stacking
- Prevents ice from absorbing freezer odors
- Easy-release rounded cube shape
Cons
- Cube size is standard, not large format
This OXO Good Grips tray is perfect for users who want controlled ice dispensing and odor protection. It’s a practical choice for keeping your freezer organized and your ice fresh.
9. Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes),
Best for: Plastic-free stainless steel for pure ice.
Crafted from premium food-grade 304 stainless steel, this Captain Cranberry ice cube tray is entirely plastic-free and non-toxic, ensuring odorless ice every time. Its retro lever handle design allows for effortless ice cube release with a single pull, eliminating the need for twisting or banging.
This 11-inch tray is made from durable stainless steel and produces 18 solid ice cubes. The included divider and integrated lever handle provide an easy, direct method for cracking cubes free. The material ensures no chemical leaching, delivering pure-tasting ice.
Pros
- Plastic-free and non-toxic stainless steel
- Retro lever handle for easy release
- Produces 18 solid ice cubes
- Odorless ice due to material
Cons
- Cubes are standard size and shape, not specialized
For those prioritizing a plastic-free kitchen, this Captain Cranberry stainless steel tray offers a durable and pure ice-making solution. Its unique lever mechanism makes serving ice convenient.
10. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball
Best for: Dual set: spheres and cubes, refill funnel.
The ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays set includes both sphere and square molds, providing 6 crystal-clear 2-inch ice balls and 6 large 2-inch square cubes per set. A bonus funnel simplifies filling, and unique bumping seals ensure perfectly round shapes. The balanced design prevents tipping for optimal use.
This bundle offers two trays: one for making six 2-inch ice balls and another for six 2-inch square cubes. Both trays feature a quick-open buckle for effortless ice release and a balanced bottom to prevent leaning. The included funnel facilitates easy water addition to the sphere mold.
Pros
- Includes both sphere and square ice molds
- Produces large 2-inch ice spheres and cubes
- Bonus funnel included for easy filling
- Quick-open buckle for effortless release
Cons
- Sphere molds require careful assembly to prevent minor leaks
This ROTTAY dual set is perfect for anyone who enjoys having both large spheres and cubes readily available. The included funnel makes preparing both types of ice exceptionally easy for any beverage.
Material Dictates Ejection and Odor
When selecting a best old ice cube tray, the primary determinant of long-term satisfaction is the material, not the shape or supposed ease-of-release. Plastic, metal, and silicone each present a distinct set of trade-offs that directly impact user experience, particularly regarding ice ejection and odor absorption.
Plastic trays, exemplified by the sturdy OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with its unique lid sliding mechanism for controlled release, often boast a rigid structure that can make one-at-a-time cube removal cumbersome if not designed with an innovative shape like OXO’s rounded cubes. However, plastic is notoriously porous and prone to absorbing freezer odors, leading to stale-tasting ice unless meticulously stored within a sealed lid or dedicated container. The stainless steel option, the Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever, offers a direct counterpoint by providing a non-porous surface that entirely eliminates odor transfer and potential plastic leaching, though its rigid metal construction requires a different approach to cube release, leveraging a lever mechanism to break the ice free.
This is where silicone truly shines, offering the best of both worlds for many users. Trays like the FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey or the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray are flexible enough to allow cubes to be pushed from the bottom, making ejection remarkably simple. Yet, unlike porous plastic, silicone’s non-stick properties, when combined with a quality food-grade formulation, resist odor absorption far better.
The Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, even offers large spheres and cubes, combining the ease of silicone with the appealing aesthetics often associated with larger ice formats, while still retaining the material’s inherent non-stick and odor-resistant advantages over traditional plastic.
Those prioritizing absolute odor-free ice and a plastic-free product will find the Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever the most suitable, despite its potentially stiffer ejection process. Conversely, for a balance of easy cube removal and good odor resistance, silicone emerges as the superior choice, with options like the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack) offering practical dual-tray functionality.
What to Look For in the Best Old Ice Cube Tray
Material and durability
When choosing your old-fashioned ice cube tray, prioritize durable materials for long-term use. Silicone trays offer superior flexibility, making ice release exceptionally simple; look for thicker silicone that resists tearing. Plastic trays, while often more rigid, can be prone to cracking over time, especially in colder temperatures.
Opt for BPA-free plastic or high-quality food-grade silicone to ensure your ice is free from harmful chemicals. For most users seeking ease and longevity, a thicker, BPA-free silicone tray is the best choice for effortless ice dispensing and consistent performance without degradation.
Capacity and size
Consider the tray’s capacity and the size of its individual cubes to match your specific needs. Trays with fewer, larger cubes are ideal for slow-melting ice in spirits or large beverages, offering a more substantial and visually appealing cube. Trays with more, smaller cubes are perfect for quickly chilling a variety of drinks or for using in blenders and ice makers where rapid ice production is key.
Evaluate the overall dimensions of the tray to ensure it fits comfortably in your freezer without obstructing other items. For efficient storage, especially in smaller freezers, select trays that are designed to stack securely on top of each other, maximizing your available space.
Which Should You Choose?
- If you want to prevent spills and odors while stacking, choose a tray with a secure, sealed lid.
- If you’re making ice for cocktails and want slow melting, look for trays that create large cubes or spheres.
- If you prioritize a plastic-free option and ease of use, consider a stainless steel tray with a lever mechanism.
- If you prefer easy-release silicone and standard-sized cubes, opt for a flexible silicone tray with a supportive base.
Quick Best Old Ice Cube Tray Buying Checklist
- Material Matters: Opt for durable, food-grade materials like silicone or BPA-free plastic.
- Cube Size: Consider if you need standard cubes, large spheres, or smaller nuggets.
- Ease of Release: Look for flexible trays that make popping out ice effortless.
- Freezer Footprint: Measure your freezer space to ensure a good fit.
- Stackability: Trays that stack well save valuable freezer real estate.
- Durability: Choose trays built to withstand repeated freezing and thawing without cracking.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Silicone Trays Better For The Best Old Ice Cube Tray?
Silicone trays are often preferred for the best old ice cube tray due to their flexibility and ease of ice release. This material makes it simple to pop out frozen cubes without breakage, unlike some rigid plastic alternatives that can become brittle over time.
What Material Is Safest For Ice Cube Trays?
The safest materials for ice cube trays are typically BPA-free plastics and food-grade silicone. These options avoid leaching harmful chemicals into your ice, ensuring that your drinking water remains pure and safe for consumption.
How Do I Prevent Ice Cubes From Sticking In My Tray?
To prevent ice cubes from sticking, consider using silicone trays which are naturally non-stick. If using plastic, briefly running the bottom of the tray under warm water can help loosen the cubes before attempting removal.
Can I Put Any Old Ice Cube Tray In The Freezer?
While most ice cube trays are designed for freezing, ensure yours is made from freezer-safe materials. Extremely brittle plastics can crack in cold temperatures, so check the product specifications for suitability.
What Size Ice Cubes Are Best For Cocktails?
For cocktails, larger ice cubes or spheres are often preferred as they melt slower, diluting the drink less. Standard-sized cubes work well for most everyday drinks and are commonly found in classic ice cube tray designs.
Final Words
Investing in the best old ice cube tray ensures a reliable way to add refreshment to your beverages. Whether you prefer classic cubes or unique shapes, these simple tools enhance everyday drinks and special occasions. Upgrade your freezer and enjoy perfectly chilled drinks anytime with a quality ice tray.